Thursday 14 March 2013

Observations on observation


A recent twitter exchange has stimulated me to revisit the topic of ‘observation’ as a purposeful activity supporting clinical teaching, learning and assessment. I first wrote about observation in 2003, when contributing to some early web-based resources for clinical teachers for the London Deanery (now a well established suite of free on-line resources). I argued that observation, at it's best, was

an active, purposeful task that stimulates deep learning and the development of professional ‘know-how’. At worst it is a passive process that leads to either heightened anxiety or total ‘shut down’ in the learner’.

At the time, I was referring to a classic approach to clinical teaching, where students are invited to observe the practice of qualified professionals and engage in a dialogue about what was observed, afterwards. I argued that it was important to maximize such learning opportunities, by making the learning opportunities explicit, including the use of ‘advance- organisers’ to help structure student’s observations by signaling the types of theoretical knowledge they might draw upon to make sense of the observed practice i.e. providing a framework to guide their observations. Drawing on the work of Karl Popper, I challenged the idea that observation is somehow an objective or ‘neutral’ process, illustrating the ways in which experienced clinicians draw upon experience and theoretical frameworks to analyse and interpret the behaviours they witness.

 Clearly the instruction “observe!” is absurd. Observation is always selective. It needs a chosen object, a definite task, an interest, a point of view, a problem.” (Popper, 1972, page 46)

In the twitter exchange, I was vicariously part of a conference session, and the observation referred to was not that of student observing teacher, rather that of teacher observing a learner, in a simulated scenario. The idea that captured my imagination was around the importance of the teacher drawing upon ‘objective’ observations as the basis of a debrief conversation designed to support further learning. I questioned the position that teacher observation was objective, suggesting that all observation is subjective, in that it is selective; the choice of what to observe is, I believe, influenced by what the observer feels to be most important or pertinent at that particular time, or in that particular situation. So, whilst it may be possible, as the teacher, to provide a ‘factual’ account of what was observed (or indeed not observed) at a behavioural level, there are limits to the usefulness of such observations. We cannot see the situation with the same eyes as the person in the middle of the action; what they notice and how they respond is something we can only infer. ( I am reminded here of a wonderful digital story called ‘Another person’s eyes’ on the Patient Voices website which beautifully captures what I am trying to express here’.)

The complexity of professional activity lies in what is not readily observable - the internal dialogue, the affective response, the reflection-in-action arising when things do not go in the way we might anticipate. The learning arising from engagement in observed work activity (whether in vivo or in simulation) is often hidden from observers view. I have blogged before about the origins of debrief being from the battlefield – where the lived experience of one participant is used as a shared resource for others around them. Asking the learner to talk you through the situation you have observed (either from memory or shared viewing of a recording) will afford insights into the ways in which they observe, read and respond to situations encountered. Inviting them to provide you with an advanced-organiser, directing you to the aspects of their performance they would most value your help with, is a powerful learner-centred strategy. Together, these approaches can form the basis of the rich, developmental conversations that support further development. By all means share your observations, drawing out similarities and differences in perspective as a way to develop insights, but be cautious about claiming objectivity!

As a footnote to this blog, I am left reflecting upon the exponential growth in the use of workplace based observations as the basis for decisions about competence. We observe a selected set of behaviours, at a given time, in a given place, for a given purpose, interpret these behaviours and make and record a judgment. This judgment is taken as an objective, portable measure of competence, i.e. a judgment that tells us about not only what was done in the observed moment, but what might be done in future comparable moments. In recording these judgments on a form, or in a portfolio, we objectify the subjective.



Reference:
Popper, K. (1972) Conjectures and refutations: the growth of scientific knowledge’

50 comments:

  1. Most continuing medical education institutions offer a complete series of learning experiences. This helps enhance the practitioner's knowledge,http://www.uk-essay.net provides updates and analysis, and expands specialized expertise.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. HACKING SERVICES💻📱📲 is need by so many individuals, and some people have actually been SCAMMED and DEFRAUDED💸 by false ❎Hackers online. 🔹COPE TECHS🔹 is an Organization that provides the best HACKING SERVICES💻📱📲 and also Solutions to TECHNOLOGY DIFFICULTIES⚙️🔧.


      We give you PROOF of our SERVICES we have offered to other Individuals.
      All our Hackers belong to the Hackers Forum HackerOne and are Top of the HackerOne's Hackers List.

      Our aim is to Help and not for the Purpose of Theft, for instance, A Man/Woman who suspects His/Her Wife/Husband of cheating and intends to monitor Her/His Calls📱, Email📧, Social media accounts💌, We do the Hack to Certify your Doubts. Another way we help is by Funding PayPal Accounts💵💶💷 for Individuals with Debts and Financial Problems.
      We also Provide Recovery Services for Individuals Who Lost Money in Bitcoin💰 Auctioning or In Forex Trading📉 and other online Stock Markets Exchange📊.
      Other Services we offer are-: Changing of Grades/Results in Universities 📚 Database, Upgrading System Security Defense☣️, and lost More. If you need Hacking Services contact us via our Email-: copetechs@gmail.com

      Delete
  2. Those who keep away from their residence nation constantly would like to continue to be attached to their own motherland and thus, новини за seek out this newspaper publishers inside their regional dialect as well as at the very least of which are part of their own nation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is crucial to achieve the love with medical so as to purchase on the web stage. Present educational institutions possess produced case study and mastering nursing colleges approaches convenient, exactly where obviously any good one who doesn't recognize anything at all regarding medical,

    ReplyDelete
  4. nice blog for students going to become a doctor.
    English Test Center Pakistan

    ReplyDelete
  5. I’m impressed with the special and informative contents that you just offer in such short timing.Learning For Hope

    ReplyDelete
  6. We offering MCSE Course London at special discount if you willing to learn then contact us.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I’m eager to find the valuable information and for me this is the right place to get the good stuff.site review

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am glad to see that people are actually writing about this issue in such a smart way, showing us all different sides to it. Thanks for sharing, please keep it up.

    Also checkout our new year 2017 wishes new collections.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ultimate article post in this blog. Thanks for sharing to us. It can help a lot to improve our knowledge
    Gone are the days when a business laid down an annual sum to have its information listed in the Yellow Pages. These days it’s crucial for all businesses to instead prominently list themselves in online directories.AIR pros is a directory of service companies in your area with a geolocation system, automatic translation of the content.The site is optimized to facilitate the referencing of referenced companies.You can search for companies by department or city and look at their profile before contacting them.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi thanks for sharing nice information.
    if you are looking
    personal trainer
    visit my site.

    ReplyDelete
  11. It's an unimpeded opportunity for people of first nations background to be, one,
    financially independent, because there is a good living to be made from first nations artwork
    and second, it offers a preservation of the traditional arts and amazing art.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "It's an unimpeded opportunity for people of first nations background to be, one,
    financially independent, because there is a good living to be made from first nations artwork
    and second, it offers a preservation of the traditional arts and Amazing Art
    "

    ReplyDelete
  13. "It's an unimpeded opportunity for people of first nations background to be, one,
    financially independent, because there is a good living to be made from first nations artwork
    and second, it offers a preservation of the traditional arts andAmazing Art"

    ReplyDelete
  14. I needed an pny to NTSC Video converter for my American TV (LCD) I bought at Best Buy and saw my choice at World-Import.com website. I inquired from the Customer Service, paid for the item via bank transfer and got the item shipped to me at Port Harcourt Nigeria via UPS-EMS within 2 weeks. The converter is of high quality, robust and portable and perfectly serves my purpose. I am happy with the product and its fast delivery and can now view all available TV channels in Nigeria. I would want to do business again and again with World-Import. Thank you Victor for your good customer relations and great service!

    ReplyDelete
  15. "I needed
    an PAL to amd vega 11 Video converter for my American amd socket bought at Best Buy and saw my choice at World-Import.com website. I inquired from the Customer Service, paid for the item via bank transfer and amd am4 shipped to me at Port Harcourt Nigeria via UPS-EMS within 2 weeks. The converter is of high quality, robust and portable and perfectly serves my purpose. I am happy with the product and its fast delivery and can now view all ryzen 5 3500
    channels in Nigeria. I would want to do business again and again with World-Import. Thank you Victor for your good customer relations and great service!"

    ReplyDelete
  16. I needed an PAL to NTSC Video converter for my American TV (LCD) I bought at Best Buy and saw my choice at World-Import.com website. I inquired from the Customer Service, paid for the item via bank transfer and got the item shipped to me at Port Harcourt Nigeria via UPS-EMS within 2 weeks. The converter is of amd socket robust and portable and perfectly serves my purpose. I am happy with the product and its fast delivery and can now view all available TV channels in Nigeria. I would want to do business again and again with World-Import. Thank you Victor for your good customer relations and great service!

    ReplyDelete
  17. There are plenty of compliments you can use to make someone feel click that
    about themselves, but certain ones can be more appropriate than others. Depending on the scenario, the compliment you give can either drive home your admiration for someone

    ReplyDelete
  18. [url=maps.google.com/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=images.google.de/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=images.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=maps.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=images.google.co.jp/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=images.google.fr/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=maps.google.fr/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]
    [url=maps.google.es/url?sa=t&url=https://surveysupportbd.com/]paypal account in bangladesh[/url]

    ReplyDelete
  19. Samanta Computer is providing up to 90% offer on Several branded Gaming Graphics Card Limited time i bought a Graphics last night.

    ReplyDelete
  20. As a footnote to this blog, I am left reflecting upon the exponential growth in the use of workplace based observations as the basis for decisions about competence. We observe a selected set of behaviours, at a given time, in a given place, for a given purpose, interpret these behaviours and make and record a judgment. This judgment is taken as an objective, portable measure of competence, i.e. a judgment that tells us about not only what was done in the observed moment, but what might be done in future comparable moments. In recording these judgments on a form, or in a portfolio, we objectify the subjective.
    wholesale salwar suit ,
    wholesale salwar kameez dealers ,

    ReplyDelete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I built my website and also get help to generate sell from Your site builder .I am highly recommending to knock them for any online service

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Arey you need best guideline for grafic design course ? so i suggested you best your Facebook site that is.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Arey you need best guideline for grafic design course ? so i suggested you best your yoursitebuilders site that is.

    ReplyDelete
  27. In the modern generation we want something best.And when we want best things about computer Accessories then our need most best things.So another best processor in bd

    ReplyDelete
  28. Are you Worried to Know Intel 10th Gen Core i3 10100 processor in bd Price in Bangladesh? let’s Discuss the Price of the Intel 10th Gen Core i3 10100 Processor. This processor comes with a new breed that come with an enabled integrated GPU, so a separate graphics card is not required for its functionality. This new 10th gen Comet Lake microarchitecture is manufactured with the 14nm process that comes with four cores but lacks in HyperThreading. As this chip is updated to the latest BIOS revision, it nicely fits into any Intel 300-series motherboard. Focusing on this, all the major motherboard manufacturers have already started BIOS updates for their 300-series lineup

    ReplyDelete
  29. Are you planning to Buy Intel 10th Gen Core i3 10105F processor in bd ? Let’s Discuss the price of the Intel 10th Gen Core i3 10105F Processor in Bangladesh. This new 10th gen Comet Lake microarchitecture is manufactured with the 14nm process that comes with four cores but lacks HyperThreading. As this chip is updated to the latest BIOS revision, it nicely fits into any Intel 400 and 500 series motherboard.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Are you worried to know AMD Ryzen 5 3600 Processor in Bangladesh (bd)? Let’s discuss the price of the AMD Ryzen 5 3600 Processor price in BD. The 3rd Generation AMD Ryzen™ desktop processors are built on the cutting-edge 7nm process, delivering a generational leap in performance and power efficiency. The new 7nm Zen 2 architecture features multiple upgrades to boost CPU and APU performance, including AMD Sense MI technology is an intelligent suite of algorithms that use artificial intelligence (AI) to predict what both the application and user want or need next

    ReplyDelete
  31. Are you worried to know AMD Ryzen 5 5600X Processor in bd price in Bangladesh? Let’s discuss the price of the AMD Ryzen 5 5600X Processor price in Bangladesh. AMD Ryzen 5 5600X Processor price deliver exceptional performance, high application responsiveness, and a host of new features for today’s modern computing experiences. Unlocked processor operating parameters allow you to overclock your CPU from the factory. But don’t stop there – AMD Store MI technology combines the speed of your SSD with the capacity of your hard drive into a single, fast, easy-to-manage drive letter for faster system boot times and speedy data access

    ReplyDelete
  32. Are you worried to know Processor price in Bangladesh? Let’s discuss the price of the AMD Ryzen 5 Pro 4650G Processor in BD. Are you looking for a powerful and affordable processor? Look no further than the AMD Ryzen 5 Pro 4650G! This processor offers great performance

    ReplyDelete
  33. Are you Worried to Know Asus Dual GeForce GTX 1650 4GB DDR5 Graphics Card Price in Bangladesh? let’s Discuss Asus Dual GeForce GTX 1650 4GB DDR5 Graphics Card Price in BD. GeForce GTX 1650 4GB GDDR5 graphics card with ultra-fast performance and great power efficiency. The perfect upgrade to advanced gaming and productivity, the GeForce GTX 1650 is built on the cutting-edge NVIDIA Turing architecture for amazing performance and stunning visuals. GeForce GTX 1650 OC Edition 4GB GDDR5. The GeForce GTX 1650 is built with the breakthrough graphics performance of the award-winning NVIDIA Turing architecture

    ReplyDelete
  34. Are you Worried to Know Asus Dual GeForce GTX 1650 4GB DDR5 Graphics Card Price in Bangladesh? let’s Discuss Asus Dual GeForce GTX 1650 4GB DDR5 Graphics Card Price in BD. GeForce GTX 1650 4GB GDDR5 graphics card with ultra-fast performance and great power efficiency. The perfect upgrade to advanced gaming and productivity, the GeForce GTX 1650 is built on the cutting-edge NVIDIA Turing architecture for amazing performance and stunning visuals. GeForce GTX 1650 OC Edition 4GB GDDR5

    ReplyDelete
  35. Women's Indian and Pakistani clothes shops in the UK & Fashion are as varied and exciting as the women who wear it. From formal to casual, sexy to elegant, we've got everything you need to look great in your clothes. We offer top brands like Cole Haan, Michael Kors and Charles David at discount prices so you can shop online with confidence! [Read more]

    ReplyDelete
  36. Women's Indian and Pakistani clothes [Shops] in the UK & Fashion are as varied and exciting as the women who wear it. From formal to casual, sexy to elegant, we've got everything you need to look great in your clothes. We offer top brands like Cole Haan, Michael Kors and Charles David at discount prices so you can shop online with confidence!

    ReplyDelete
  37. Upto 70% off on Anarkalis, get 2in1 Heavy Net Zari Embroidered and Stonework Slit Anarkali from Laakha

    ReplyDelete
  38. Buy fitness equipment from best online shop , SportFitzone in USA. Also Enjoy Upto 50% Off Price on All Types of Gym or exercise equipment from SportFitzone in USA

    ReplyDelete
  39. Are you setting up your kitchen and looking for the most relevant products and accessories? This is the page for you, we've got all the kitchenware items you need to start creating your own bakery, kitchen or whatever it is you want.

    ReplyDelete
  40. M2designstudiollcoffers you premium quality graphic designing/proofreading and editing/self publishing services so if you want good quality then you are in the right place.m2designstudiollc

    ReplyDelete
  41. https://factsproviders.com/best-20-selfish-toxic-mother-quotes/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Are you looking for information on the Intel i3 13100 price in Bangladesh. Now we will tell you about the price of the Intel i3 13100 Raptor Lake processor in bd. The price of the Intel i3 13100 in Bangladesh is 17,000 BDT at our store. This makes Intel i3 13100 a budget-friendly option for those looking for a processor that can handle everyday tasks. One of the standout features of the Intel 13th Gen Core i3 13100 is its 4 cores and 8 threads. This allows for smooth multitasking and efficient processing, which is especially important if you’re using your computer for work or school.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Do you want to know about Graphic Design? Lets cheak our website and Collect your information

    ReplyDelete
  44. Do you want to Improve your home? Lets cheak our website and Select which item do you want for.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Do you want to know about any facts information. Lets visit our website and find what you need.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Experience top-tier SEO services with Barakah Marketing Agency! Our expert team leverages cutting-edge strategies to enhance your online visibility and drive organic traffic. From keyword optimization to backlink building, we ensure your website ranks higher on search engines, attracting more potential customers. Partner with Barakah Marketing Agency and unlock the power of SEO for unprecedented business growth.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Golfing tee shirts are like a badge of honor, proudly declaring my affiliation with the golfing community.Do you want to get offer price on Golfing tee shirts? Lets cheak our website and Select which item do you want for.

    ReplyDelete